Years ago, rumors began to circulate that Nintendo was working on a remake of one of the most consequential and critically acclaimed video games of all time - The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. When I first heard these rumors, I wrote them off because I did not see Nintendo doing such a remake; it sounded like one of those dream announcements that would never happen. My theory was that we were, at best, going to get a remaster of the 3DS version, with small changes to make it look good on a bigger screen. Well, I was proven wrong earlier this year , and now Nintendo has unveiled a whole lot more. There’s so much to unpack that I had to sit down and write my thoughts out beyond just posting on social media about how excited I was.
The Importance of Ocarina of Time
Despite the view it may have with gamers today and the recency bias to dismiss it in a sea of games like Cyberpunk 2077, The Witcher III, The Last of Us, and Bioshock; Ocarina of Time is, for the most part, recognized by many places as the most likely pick for the greatest video game of all time. Now, I’m not here to debate for or against whether it deserves that distinction or where it places in today’s lists, but it is essentially the Citizen Kane of video games. Citizen Kane may not be everyone’s pick for the greatest movie of all time, but it is seen from a historical lens and film school in that way. No matter how you feel about it, Ocarina of Time is one of the most consequential games and Miyamoto’s magnum opus.
When it was released in 1998, Ocarina of Time put the formula forward, not just for 3D Zelda, but for many action RPGs of the time. The jump to 3D was still a challenge for many developers, and Nintendo worked on ways to tackle those challenges with this entry in the iconic series, using mechanics such as Z-targeting and a huge open world to explore. It changed everything for video games at the time and helped make possible future titles like The Witcher III and Fable. Add in one of the better stories in the franchise and a soundtrack so good that you instantly recognize it even after 28 years, and you had the game of the decade.
For me personally, it can’t be overstated how important this game is to me. Most of my time playing games before Ocarina of Time was spent playing Mario games. Sure, I would play other games, but I mostly played Mario. That started to change when I got my N64 and we began to rent games at our local Blockbuster. In 1999, I took a chance and rented Ocarina of Time. The first time I saw Hyrule Field, it was a sense of magic that I have only relived in gaming very few times since then. I didn’t finish the game during my first playthrough (we had to return it), but I came away with something else. I knew after I experienced it that this video game thing would be more than just a kids‘ thing; I was going to be a part of this hobby for the rest of my life. It had that deep of an impact on me, and I don’t think younger gamers quite realize how much this game affected people at the time.

The Polarizing Reaction to the Art Direction and Graphics
When Nintendo had Aonuma pop into the Zelda 40th Anniversary Direct and start to play the remake, I was blown away. The N64-PS1 era is the one era that hasn’t aged well visually and mechanically, despite the importance of the 3D jump. So, to see a game that you had to grow up with to appreciate the visuals and look like a brand-new modern title is like a dream come true. We’ve seen fan projects, but this just made it more of a reality.
Now, when I got online, I immediately saw some negativity towards the visuals. I wasn’t fully shocked because it’s social media, and unfortunately, there were people ready to hate on it before they even saw it. I also have a theory that I call the “legacy sequel” theory, which states that legacy sequels to films start with an unfair advantage because once people watch those films and don’t get the same feeling as the original, they don’t give the new film a chance. I think there’s some of that happening here, although this is a remake rather than a sequel to a beloved film. However, I do think there are criticisms to be made in the art direction. I believe there are moments and renders that have a shiny, almost porcelain-like look, and the game’s visuals take you aback, presenting with modern graphics that give off an Unreal Engine fan project vibe.
I think this has to do with people’s expectations not matching what they had in their heads and when you take a major game like this that impacted so many people, you are going to judge it much more. Also, Nintendo recently hasn’t been known for pushing graphics since the “blue ocean” era of the company started. However, with the Switch 2 we are seeing them start to push that graphical barrier more and more, so it’s creating an uncanny valley feel since we aren’t used to the company doing that in quite some time. I do think it’s okay to point this out and say the game looks weird to you, but I think some people weren’t fans of calling it AI-looking. We are in a brave (and scary) world and we are still forming how to talk about things with AI being part of it now. I am in the camp that’s not a fan of calling anything you don’t like AI or slop, it just enters a iffy territory when humans are involved.
For me, I see what Nintendo is doing here. Part of the reason it has that doll-like look mixed with realism is that they are trying to preserve the art style and art direction of the original. I’m happy they are doing this because I don’t want Ocarina of Time to not look like the specific look and personality it had during that time, including the one Majora’s Mask used. I’m also admittedly biased because I’ve always preferred the OOT/MM art direction over all the ones that have come after.

Ready to Rediscover
So, obviously, I am extremely happy with the way this remake looks. So what about everything else? Well, I’m mixed on the game seemingly being a 1:1 remake. Although it doesn’t seem to be absolutely 1:1, as there are small tweaks to gameplay mechanics, and the additional extended cutscenes are trying to add a cinematic flair. I was hoping for more changes, but I think it’ll still be fine overall, although I expect younger gamers to lament the lack of things to do in Hyrule Field (unless they are hiding something, of course).
While there’s plenty of nostalgia to pass around here, they are doing a good job catering to new and modern gamers as well. The jump and free camera sound weird as mechanics to praise, but newcomers don’t realize how strange that’s going to be to have in the game now. The environments look bigger and more sparse, because as time goes on, that big open world in the original was starting to feel smaller , and we got a taste of bigger games. You can also see some UI elements from the recent games, and the addition of voices makes sense since that’s becoming the norm in the franchise.
When the game comes out, I expect it to have great reviews, not to the level of the original release, but overall solid scores that will reaffirm why this is among the greatest games of all time. Do I think it’s a Game of the Year winner? I expect it to be nominated, but I don’t think it’ll win because voters will feel the legacy of the game is secured overall and they’ll want to go with something newer, especially with some of the recent hype around Blood of the Dawnwalker. I am ready to go on this adventure once again and for many to discover it for the first time. It won’t 100% show them why this game was so special to us, but hopefully, it makes them see why it has the legacy it has.
I’m also interested to know if we are getting a small peek into the next Zelda. I don’t know what engine this is, but it could be what powers the next mainline entry. Something to keep in mind as you play.




I wasn't really sold on the remake at first, but as I saw it, I've come around to it. Also, while the game is great for it to be played again, it does kind of need some of what is looking to be quality-of-life improvements (jump, camera etc). More to hook the newer players.
I'm okay with them doing a near 1:1 simply for the fact that the skeleton of this was always good, as you said this game probably inspired so many and is a Citizen Kane level type of thing for games as a whole.
I'm with you also on I like OoT/MM style more than, say, Wind Waker. I dunno if they will want to use this as a base for a future game, as honestly ToK did kind of close the story but left things open as well.
Whatever the case, even if it's a remake, Nintendo seems to get the assignment and is putting in the effort that is needed, and it doesn't feel like a cash grab for nostalgia.