The Xbox division is in an interesting spot. On one hand the last few years have been rough for the Series consoles, which after a pretty good start, began to sell less and less and debates around their identity and the effectiveness of Game Pass controlled the conversation. At the same time, this year has seen a roller coaster of bad news with layoffs combined with good news of reorganization and what seems to be a better vision with a surprising new leader for the brand. You also have Xbox actually winning the PR war against PlayStation for the first time in a long time. It’s safe to say we are in a transition that could see the industry twist and turn, and it’s all due to a woman who seemingly came out of nowhere.
The Phil Era is Aging Worse and Worse
If there’s one video game executive I’ve written a million articles about, it’s Phil Spencer. My reading of Phil in Xbox and gaming history was mostly positive up until the last two to three years. I originally saw Phil as a Michael Eisner type for a very long time, a man who came in and saved a sibling brand and turned it into a powerhouse beyond what it was when it started. Then I saw him more as a President Grant, a man who did a lot of good for the United States but left under the shadow of an economic depression and scandals in his cabinet. Now, I’m starting to think of Phil more and more as a Jimmy Carter.
Jimmy Carter is recognized as one of the better humans to have occupied the White House and has recently received more recognition for successes the press ignored at the time, such as healing the country after Watergate, implementing the fiscal policy that eventually ended the stagflation of the 70s, and his Camp David Accords between Israel and Egypt. However, he is also known for being terrible at handling crises, especially international ones. Richard Norton Smith, one of my favorite presidential historians, has called him the unluckiest president the U.S. ever had. The more time has passed, the more I think I see Phil in a similar way to Carter.
Phil, like Jimmy, is very likable and is a genuine gamer. In his first several years, he was known as a voice in a sea of executives, and he set some major policies and plans that led to record-breaking revenue for Xbox. He expanded the ecosystem by including PC and launched the polarizing Game Pass. He also initiated (with Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella’s approval) the biggest cash acquisition in history. However, I think much of the pain that’s being caused today in layoffs and why there even needs to be a “reset” is due to him.
It seems Phil sort of checked out in the final years, and the studios were never given proper leadership. It’s obvious to me that they were messy and had too much freedom, which led to long development cycles and constant delays. Don’t get me started on what happened with Perfect Dark, which was a mess. I understand sticking up for developers, and I’m with people on that, but you can’t let Perfect Dark languish like that. The ignorance to ignore certain things fans want , like Rare IP or to just get Halo right, is all on Phil. Phil also made a dumb move with his obsession with Game Pass.
I’ve defended Game Pass many times, but I’ll be the first to say that trying to create the “Netflix of video games” when the infrastructure to even attempt that is probably a decade or two away was stupid. Game Pass can work with certain moves, making it more of a discoverability platform rather than the main focus. Now, Phil left Microsoft with a lot of studios that had an indie personality (nothing wrong with that, by the way!), and now they were forced to “trim the fat,” which uprooted people’s lives all because he was obsessed with making something work.
Actually, as I write this and make historical comparisons, it feels like what happened with Ronald Reagan. A president who came in and fixed America’s image, brought confidence back, rushed the Soviet Union’s collapse, embraced an image of America as a place for immigrants, and an image of 1980s Americana. However, there were long-term problems, such as evidence that his policies may have created middle class spirals and wealth disparity that we are dealing with today. In many ways, Phil is like Jimmy, but his Xbox is like Reagan; great for the moment, but issues that needed to be solved in the long term.

The New Boss
So, here we are in a new era for the green brand that started with a bang and a shock. Phil randomly announced his resignation; Sarah Bond, who seemed to be the heir apparent, seems to have been passed over and has resigned, and then someone new steps in. Asha is not a gamer or gaming person (although she says she’s trying to understand it more), but from the moment she stepped into the role, it’s been go, go, go.
Asha’s very first step was to get rid of the “This is an Xbox” campaign. Now, I didn’t hate this campaign because I understood what Microsoft was trying to convey, but I do think that if the people at Xbox hated it, it was the right thing to do to eliminate it. She also emphasized this was Xbox (or as she now deems it - XBOX) and not Microsoft Gaming. She then entered “trim the fat” mode. And look, I just want to say that yes, I think it sucks that this stage includes laying off thousands when it’s all set and done, getting rid of studios, and consolidation, but this had to be done for Xbox to survive. The division was unorganized and a complete mess. If it didn’t get reorganized, it would have continued to have the same problems. That doesn’t mean what’s happening to the people affected is okay, but it’s one of those things where business and labor collide in a catch-22 situation.
So now, it seems we know what Asha’s Xbox is going to be. The exclusives (or at least a good chunk) are back. The emphasis on Game Pass is low. The studios and publishing division are organized and seemingly focused. This is no longer Phil’s baby; this is her baby now, and she has to show that she can overcome the damage to the brand and do this. Credit to her; she doesn’t seem to be stopping. She got a consequential creator in Hideo Kojima to come on board, she’s focusing on the next generation Xbox platform, and she’s still wanting feedback from fans.
It’s funny because people were worried about Asha not being a gamer. Sometimes you need that outside voice; a true believer can be good too, but Phil was in that camp and stayed longer than he should have. Asha brings outside eyes and is outside the bubble, which may be her secret power.

What’s Next?
Here’s my personal theory on what comes next for Xbox. The first thing is the new organization of the publishing and studio groups. I think what’s left for Xbox Game Studios becomes exclusive to the platform, so Gears, Fable, Forza, and Clockwork Revolution. Activision is going to be full-blown multiplatform with Call of Duty, Spyro, Crash, Sea of Thieves, and Age of Empires. The wildcard here is Halo because I do think Xbox wants to keep Halo exclusive from now on, but it’s now in Activision. Maybe the campaign is exclusive, and multiplayer goes multiplatform.
Then, we have Bethesda, which I think becomes a case-by-case basis. I do think there’s a chance Elder Scrolls VI is exclusive or potentially a timed exclusive. The Fallout games might get the same treatment. I’m not sure about anything id Software makes, and obviously, the online games stay multiplatform. Of course, Blizzard is fully multiplatform, although for all we know, the new Starcraft shooter is exclusive. This makes a focused approach that takes away questions and makes Xbox both a platform holder with exclusives, as well as a major publisher that can make revenue and get more players across multiple devices and ecosystems. It’s like a fusion of the old Xbox with Phil’s Xbox.
Last, but not least, we have the next generation - Helix. There’s a bit of mystery surrounding Helix because we still don’t know if Steam will be on it, how many types of devices there will be, and how they are going to sell this to us. This will be critical for Asha and Xbox to get right if they even have a chance at mattering anymore. This, even more than the current “reset,“ will be Asha’s biggest challenge, and we’ll see how it works out a year or two from now.




Xbox has become more and more appealing under the Asha Sharma era than it ever was during Phil Spencer's reign of terror.
Though I think Phil did a great job saving the Xbox One, he completely wrecked the brand with the Series X/S generation.
For the first time in over a decade, I'm actually excited about Xbox and hope they can make a major comeback heading into next gen.
These are interesting observations. I still don't think Xbox appeals to me at the moment - all those brands and franchises I'm simply not interested in on a personal level, though clearly many are. Things might change in the future. At least there seems to be somewhat of an identity coming through now - multiplayer games that keep you hooked, with some high level single player adventure games. All seems focused towards the young adult age group.
What I'm more interested in is how Xbox (and Sony too) will be able to keep making games but at an affordable level. If hardware cost is going to increase, I don't want to see either platform just play it safe and make the same generic games over and over, I want to see some creativity. I think both of them are not too focused on that side of the industry and too focused on numbers and quarterly revenue. That will grab my attention more I think.